Where a City’s Labor Data Is Really Its County’s

The Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes labor figures for cities of 25,000 or more. For smaller places, and for some larger ones the Bureau does not report separately, the only figure available is the county’s. Here is how often a profile shows one.

Of the 4,211 published city profiles that carry a labor force figure, 2,520 (60%) show the figure for the county that contains the city rather than one measured for the city itself. Each of those profiles says so, in the table row and in the sentence above it. This counts how often that is the case.

Key findings

  • Among cities under 15,000 residents, 99% show a county figure. Among cities of 50,000 or more, 10% do.
  • In 2,384 of the 2,520 (95%), the labor force shown is larger than the city’s entire population, so it cannot describe the city.
  • Among the 37 states with 25 or more published cities, the share runs from 35% in Massachusetts to 100% in Hawaii.
  • The most extreme case is Malibu, CA: a city of 10,421 people showing a labor force of 5,031,013, the figure for Los Angeles County, CA.

It depends mostly on size

City populationProfilesShowing a county figureShare
Under 15,0001,2161,20699%
15,000 to 24,9991,1331,00589%
25,000 to 49,99998422423%
50,000 or more8788510%
Published city profiles with a labor force figure, by city population. Download this table (CSV)

It varies a great deal by state

StatePublished citiesShowing a county figureShare
Hawaii3434100%
Puerto Rico2929100%
Maryland13912993%
New York20116281%
Louisiana564377%
New Jersey15811975%
Virginia1279373%
Pennsylvania866171%
Florida34824370%
Ohio17211667%
Missouri875766%
Washington1338665%
Kentucky463065%
Wisconsin976264%
Oregon694464%
Georgia1126760%
Colorado704260%
South Carolina633860%
Alabama704057%
Tennessee673857%
Minnesota1025756%
Oklahoma452556%
Mississippi422355%
Illinois22612254%
North Carolina965254%
Indiana864653%
Arizona683653%
Texas26913550%
Michigan1015050%
Arkansas391846%
Connecticut351646%
Kansas351646%
Iowa421945%
Idaho251144%
California49821443%
Utah672842%
Massachusetts893135%
Share of a state’s published cities that show a county labor force figure, for states with 25 or more. Download this table (CSV)

Where the mismatch is largest

CityPopulationLabor force shownWhose figure it isLabor force ÷ population
Malibu, CA10,4215,031,013Los Angeles County, CA483×
Lyons, IL10,3392,707,833Cook County, IL262×
Galena Park, TX10,4872,548,851Harris County, TX243×
Paradise Valley, AZ12,6112,446,067Maricopa County, AZ194×
San Diego Country Estates, CA10,2231,639,952San Diego County, CA160×
Rossmoor, CA11,5321,601,928Orange County, CA139×
Westwood Lakes, FL10,5531,452,691Miami-Dade County, FL138×
Lake Morton-Berrydale, WA11,1831,352,310King County, WA121×
Home Gardens, CA10,5061,183,558Riverside County, CA113×
Lighthouse Point, FL10,6001,071,312Broward County, FL101×
For each county, the city whose displayed labor force is largest relative to its own population; the ten most extreme. A labor force well under a city’s population is plausible; one above it is not. Download this table (CSV)

The largest cities that show a county figure

CityPopulationLabor force shownWhose figure it isLabor force ÷ population
Nashville-Davidson, TN690,130428,402Davidson County, TN0.62×
Louisville/Jefferson County, KY631,818401,854Jefferson County, KY0.64×
Urban Honolulu, HI345,482479,799Honolulu County, HI1.39×
San Juan, PR317,995147,252San Juan Municipio, PR0.46×
Enterprise, NV240,4641,229,087Clark County, NV5.11×
Arlington, VA236,254150,002Arlington County, VA0.63×
Spring Valley, NV219,1871,229,087Clark County, NV5.61×
Augusta-Richmond County, GA201,52886,930Richmond County, GA0.43×
The eight largest cities that show a county labor force figure. A labor force below a city’s population is plausible; one above it is not. Download this table (CSV)

Size does not settle whether the county’s figure is a fair stand-in. Of these eight, 5 show a labor force at or below the city’s own population, so the county figure is a plausible stand-in there. 3 show one above it, so it is not.

A county figure describes the county. It is a close description of a city only where the city and the county cover nearly the same people, and it says almost nothing about a small place inside a large county. The unemployment rate on all of these profiles is the county’s as well.

Methodology

Every published city profile that carries a labor force figure. A profile is counted as showing a county figure when the stored measurement records that the number belongs to a larger area, in the wording “This is the figure for” followed by that area, which the profile itself prints beside the figure. As a check that such a figure cannot be the city’s own, it is compared with the city’s population from the same profile: a labor force cannot exceed the number of people living there. Size bands use the same population. States with fewer than 25 published cities are left out of the state comparison, since a share of a handful is not a pattern.

Sources

Related

Every figure here is recalculated from the same measurements the profiles use. See the methodology for how the underlying data is collected and normalized, and the editorial policy for how these reports are written.