Compare

43311 vs 46176

Which is the better fit for you?

43311 — Bellefontaine, OH
Area Score

Missing required signal: growth.

46176 — Shelbyville, IN
70
Area Score
Top 18% nationally

Signals

43311
46176
Opportunity
58 · Top 44%
vs
66 · Top 28%
Climate
61 · Bottom 19%
vs
68 · Bottom 45%
Physical resilience
71 · Top 35%
vs
68 · Top 39%
Housing affordability
99 · Top 11%
vs
100 · Top 10%
Schools
69 · Top 27%
vs
59 · Top 40%
Access
80 · Bottom 22%
vs
86 · Bottom 30%
Economic stability
50 · Bottom 33%
vs
47 · Bottom 29%

Measured values

Metric4331146176Source period
Population20,39128,7822024 ACS 5-Year
Median household income$67,914$65,1822024 ACS 5-Year
Per capita income$34,814$34,9082024 ACS 5-Year
Population density196/sq mi170/sq mi2024 ACS 5-Year
Median home value$207,600$194,4002024 ACS 5-Year
Median gross rent$850$9852024 ACS 5-Year
Homeownership rate67.4%64.4%2024 ACS 5-Year
Unemployment rate3.2%3.3%June 2026
Employment change (year over year)-0.6%-0.6%June 2026
Bachelor's degree or higher17.3%21.3%2024 ACS 5-Year
Poverty rate13.5%16.6%2024 ACS 5-Year
Average July high83°F86°F1991-2020 Normals
Average January low18°F22°F1991-2020 Normals
Annual precipitation42.6"43.1"1991-2020 Normals
Distance to major airport40 mi31 miNASR current cycle
Average commute21.2 min24.0 min2024 ACS 5-Year
Median age37.739.82024 ACS 5-Year
Public schools8102024-25 school year
Students per teacher14.8915.912024-25 school year
Math proficiency65.0%43.7%2019-20 school year
Reading proficiency62.6%38.0%2019-20 school year
Free or reduced-price lunch eligibility47.8%47.4%2024-25 school year

A bolded value is the more favorable of the two where the metric has a clear direction. Metrics like population and density have no inherent better or worse and are shown unweighted.

Ohio and Indiana do not give the same test. Each state writes its own assessment and sets its own passing score, so the two proficiency rows above are not directly comparable — the difference between them partly measures which standard is harder. Students per teacher and the school count are unaffected, and each profile ranks its own proficiency within its own state.

Physical risk tradeoff

43311

Elevated or high exposure: earthquake, tornado.

46176

Elevated or high exposure: tornado, earthquake, cold wave.

Your best match

Weight what matters to you. Your preferences stay in this browser and never change either Area Score.

43311
70
Your Score
Area Score
46176
69
Your Score
70
Area Score

Select your priorities to see which of the two fits them better.

Full profiles: 43311 — Bellefontaine, OH · 46176 — Shelbyville, IN · How this is calculated: methodology

43311 vs 46176: Location Comparison | AreaProfile