Compare

19454 vs 11725

Which is the better fit for you?

19454 — Montgomeryville, PA
Area Score

Missing required signal: growth.

11725 — Commack, NY
Area Score

Missing required signals: opportunity, growth.

Signals

19454
11725
Climate
70 · Bottom 48%
vs
70 · Top 50%
Physical resilience
91 · Top 9%
vs
95 · Top 4%
Housing affordability
90 · Top 32%
vs
87 · Top 38%
Schools
85 · Top 7%
vs
82 · Top 12%
Access
90 · Bottom 39%
vs
87 · Bottom 32%
Economic stability
81 · Top 9%
vs
81 · Top 10%

Measured values

Metric1945411725Source period
Population27,75529,0732024 ACS 5-Year
Median household income$118,177$168,2812024 ACS 5-Year
Per capita income$61,712$66,1082024 ACS 5-Year
Population density2,248/sq mi2,994/sq mi2024 ACS 5-Year
Median home value$457,900$670,0002024 ACS 5-Year
Median gross rent$1,766$2,6222024 ACS 5-Year
Homeownership rate77.7%92.6%2024 ACS 5-Year
Bachelor's degree or higher56.4%59.2%2024 ACS 5-Year
Poverty rate4.6%4.4%2024 ACS 5-Year
Average July high85°F83°F1991-2020 Normals
Average January low24°F25°F1991-2020 Normals
Distance to major airport24 mi30 miNASR current cycle
Average commute31.2 min33.0 min2024 ACS 5-Year
Median age46.841.62024 ACS 5-Year
Public schools472024-25 school year
Students per teacher13.7211.632024-25 school year
Math proficiency50.2%57.0%2019-20 school year
Reading proficiency67.8%76.0%2019-20 school year
Free or reduced-price lunch eligibility24.8%16.5%2024-25 school year

A bolded value is the more favorable of the two where the metric has a clear direction. Metrics like population and density have no inherent better or worse and are shown unweighted.

Pennsylvania and New York do not give the same test. Each state writes its own assessment and sets its own passing score, so the two proficiency rows above are not directly comparable — the difference between them partly measures which standard is harder. Students per teacher and the school count are unaffected, and each profile ranks its own proficiency within its own state.

Physical risk tradeoff

19454

No hazard reaches elevated exposure.

11725

Elevated or high exposure: coastal flooding, hurricane.

Your best match

Weight what matters to you. Your preferences stay in this browser and never change either Area Score.

19454
85
Your Score
Area Score
11725
84
Your Score
Area Score

Select your priorities to see which of the two fits them better.

Full profiles: 19454 — Montgomeryville, PA · 11725 — Commack, NY · How this is calculated: methodology

19454 vs 11725: Location Comparison | AreaProfile